| Original & Important Owners | Current Owner | Location | Year Awarded |
| Dr. Daniel Berry - Harriett Vaught | Bethany Scates |
Third St., Carmi | 1970 |
| North Storms - Boyer - Pomeroy | Mr. and Mrs. Jack Leithliter | Third St., Carmi | 1970 |
| W.W. Gray - Abner Carey* | Sherry Carey Garcia - for sale |
Grayville | 1970 |
| John M. Crebs - Evans | The Social
House LLC |
Main St, Carmi | 1971 |
| James Logan | Mr. and Mrs. Jack Sailer | Emma area | 1971 |
| W.F. Elliot - Eleanor Pomeroy | Mark and Becky Stanley | Main St, Carmi | 1972 |
| Dr. Thomas Long - Land - Barlow | Mr. and Mrs. Scott Healy | Enfield | 1972 |
| Lucy Crebs Berry - Pearce - Brown | Formerly Pud Williams - New owners |
Third St., Carmi | 1973 |
| George W. Webb - Angiel - Flower | Janet Ronalds Walker | North St, Grayville | 1973 |
| Chauncey Conger | Mr. and Mrs. Steven Hyatt |
Stewart St, Carmi | 1974 |
| Felix Viskniskki - Joe Jackson | Cindy Birk Conley | Walnut St, Carmi | 1974 |
| John Hanna | torn down by family |
Big Prairie | 1974 |
| Wesley Gold Boyer - Finch - Newcomb | Mr and Mrs. Jack Martin | Third St., Carmi | 1975 |
| Isadore A. Shipley - Finch | Kent "Pete" Fulkerson |
Third St., Carmi | 1978 |
| Frances M. Lanterman - Munsey | Dennis Loven - may have burned |
Grayville | 1979 |
| Henry Slater Land | Powell Land - still in family | Big Prairie | 1980 |
| Rufus Stinson - Ivan Elliott | Mr and Mrs Robert Newingham | Third St., Carmi | 1982 |
| Henry Philhour | Mr. and Mrs. Harold Sutton | Omaha area | 1983 |
| Allen McClain Stum | Mr. and Mrs. Jack Rawlinson | Crossville | 1985 |
| James Morrison | Letha Coale Miller estate |
Burnt Prairie | 1986 |
| Joseph L. Bennett | Joe and Betty West | Hawthorne Twp | 1987 |
| Col. Everton Conger | Brian and Holly Kirkpatrick | Main St, Carmi | 1989 |
| Louis Haas and
Helen Conger Haas |
Keith and Sandra Johnson |
Third St., Carmi | 1990 |
| Dr. John Lehman - Barnes | Mr. and Mrs. Matt Healy | Oak & 6th, Carmi | 1991 |
| Cleveland
- Coston family |
David and Marcia Coston |
Phillipstown areas |
1991 |
| Stinnett Family -
Stein |
David and Sarah Stanley Brown | First St, Carmi | 1992 |
| American Womens League* | Blake and Jessica Williams |
Main St, Carmi | 1993 |
| Albert Ransom Goodman | Fred and Brenda Smith | Church St, Carmi | 1994 |
| Webb-Hay - Boeger | Glenn and Mary Coleman |
Main Cross, Carmi | 1995 |
| Frances Parrish - John Powell - Hale | David and Phoebe Port |
Main St, Carmi | 1996 |
| James Robert Williams "Castle"* | Glenn Coleman |
Main St, Carmi | 1997 |
| William Smith | Daniel and Ruth Drury, home is for sale | Third St., Carmi | 1999 |
| John M. Crebs "Chestnut Grove" - Williams | Jane Absher | Carmi Twp | 2000 |
| Arthur Charles - McCallister | Scott and Lindell Duvall Rice | Main St, Carmi | 2001 |
| Morris Blasker | Terry and Tresa Gholson | Main St, Carmi | 2002 |
| John R. Jones - Rice - Stanley | Rebecca Stanley | Main St, Carmi | 2003 |
| Melrose Hotel-Campbell Funeral Home | David and Sharon Campbell | Main St, Carmi | 2004 |
| Robert and Florence
Hurley - Endicottl |
James Robert amd Virginia
Endicott |
5th Street, Carmi |
2006 |
*Listed on National Register of Historic Places
National register info is available from the National Park Service at:
http://www.nationalregisterofhistoricplaces.com/IL/White/state.html
and from the Illinois Historic Preservation Agency at:
http://www.illinoishistory.gov
They used to have a list of honored properties but don't see
it now.
In some of the early years several awards were given, while there was no award the year Cecil Hucker was society president, which we think was 1988. In 1998 the society had a joint fall meeting with the Home Culture Circle, a General Federal of Women's Clubs member, which was celebrating its 100th anniversary. The group organized Carmi's first library in the Ratcliff Inn building, and was instrumental in obtaining Carnegie funding for the 1914 library. In 2005 there was no award due to events surrounding the Key Ingredients Exhibit in Carmi. The final award was given in 2014 to the Robinson Stewart House, which is already on the National Register. Long-time Chairman Kent F.P. Boeger had retired after the 2006 award. Originally, only homes 100 years or older were considered for the award, along with integrity, restoration efforts, and historic significance. Please help us with changes in ownership or errors we have made in linking the photos.
